Site menu:

RSS BBC Cricket


Warning: Attempt to assign property of non-object in /home/cfogarty/public_html/wp-includes/rss.php on line 440

RSS Telegraph

RSS Live Scores

Archives

Recent Posts

Site search

RSS ABC

Links:

Admin

Buttony Things

Ian Healy’s great idea

Umpire B Doctrove just made a great decision on the final day of the Perth test. Standing strong against a vociferous appeal from Warne and company, the umpire correctly ruled that the turning leggie marginally pitched outside leg.

Ian Healy commenting on the game, made a great observation;

“A great use of technology would be for the third umpire to radio down to Doctrove and let him know he just made a great decision”

Healy’s point was that the umpire may be wondering whether he ruled correctly or not in the face of such a strong appeal. To be informed that he called correctly would be a great confidence boost.

Of course there is a down side to this suggestion. Namely that if the practise gets adopted and the umpire’s radio goes silent after a close call then he knows he made a stinker!

Comments

Comment from S Jagadish
Time: December 21, 2005, 2:27 am

Doctrove gave a dodgy one today, I don’t think Ashwell Prince was out lbw to Warne. The ball seemed headed over the stumps and seemed to me that it would have missed leg. Thankfully South Africa survived. Actually I don’t really like South Africa, but it is nice to see that a side can suffer poor decisions (including the Ponting one in Australia’s first inngs) in Australia and yet draw the game.

Comment from Chris
Time: December 21, 2005, 9:56 am

Overall though I thought he (Doctrove) had a reasonable game. Who’d be an umpire these days?

Write a comment